{
  "schema_version": 2,
  "dataset_version": "1.0.0+5b4307882dc4",
  "release_date": "2026-08-19",
  "purpose": "Precision-oriented Pattern Lens retrieval regression over reviewed positive reasoning connections from the bounded public corpus.",
  "primary_metric": "expected_pattern_hit_at_3",
  "evidence_limit": "Engineering regression only. The cases are curated positive controls, not an independent benchmark, not statistical precision/recall, and not evidence of language-learning efficacy.",
  "architecture": "hybrid deterministic retrieval: literal reusable-formula evidence + reviewed categorical public reasoning cues",
  "reasoning_strength_policy": "direct > supported > prompt; categorical editorial evidence, not probability",
  "thresholds": {
    "expected_pattern_hit_at_3": 0.95,
    "expected_move_hit_at_3": 0.95
  },
  "metrics": {
    "cases": 18,
    "expected_pattern_top_1": 0.8889,
    "expected_pattern_hit_at_3": 1,
    "expected_pattern_hit_at_6": 1,
    "expected_move_hit_at_3": 1,
    "expected_pattern_with_reasoning_evidence": 1,
    "expected_pattern_with_literal_evidence": 0.1111,
    "expected_pattern_with_both_signals": 0.1111
  },
  "cases": [
    {
      "id": "PL01",
      "language": "en",
      "sentence": "This issue has led to a drop in our customer satisfaction ratings.",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF059",
      "expected_move": "Cause",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "en-cause-led",
        "reasoning_move": "Cause",
        "intent_id": "connect-cause-and-effect",
        "pattern_id": "CLF059",
        "strength": "direct",
        "scope": "frame_structure",
        "evidence": "explicit causal result cue"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF059",
          "reasoning_move": "Cause",
          "score": 18,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "connect-cause-and-effect",
            "strength": "direct",
            "evidence": "explicit causal result cue"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL02",
      "language": "en",
      "sentence": "Why did our sales drop?",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF060",
      "expected_move": "Cause",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "en-cause-why",
        "reasoning_move": "Cause",
        "intent_id": "explain-a-cause",
        "pattern_id": "CLF060",
        "strength": "prompt",
        "scope": "intent_prompt",
        "evidence": "why-question asks for a cause"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF060",
          "reasoning_move": "Cause",
          "score": 14,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "explain-a-cause",
            "strength": "prompt",
            "evidence": "why-question asks for a cause"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL03",
      "language": "de",
      "sentence": "Zu viel Alkohol führt zu Leberproblemen.",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF059",
      "expected_move": "Cause",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "literal+reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [
        "führt zu",
        "führt"
      ],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "de-cause-fuehrt",
        "reasoning_move": "Cause",
        "intent_id": "connect-cause-and-effect",
        "pattern_id": "CLF059",
        "strength": "direct",
        "scope": "frame_structure",
        "evidence": "führt zu"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF059",
          "reasoning_move": "Cause",
          "score": 28.3,
          "evidence_type": "literal+reasoning",
          "hits": [
            "führt zu",
            "führt"
          ],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "connect-cause-and-effect",
            "strength": "direct",
            "evidence": "führt zu"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL04",
      "language": "en",
      "sentence": "Can you write down the advantages and disadvantages of each option to help visualize and compare them?",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF047",
      "expected_move": "Decide",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "en-decide-tradeoff",
        "reasoning_move": "Decide",
        "intent_id": "choose-between-options",
        "pattern_id": "CLF047",
        "strength": "direct",
        "scope": "frame_structure",
        "evidence": "trade-off vocabulary"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF047",
          "reasoning_move": "Decide",
          "score": 18,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "choose-between-options",
            "strength": "direct",
            "evidence": "trade-off vocabulary"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "CLF064",
          "reasoning_move": "Compare",
          "score": 18,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "compare-alternatives",
            "strength": "direct",
            "evidence": "explicit comparison cue"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "GRP055",
          "reasoning_move": null,
          "score": 6.2,
          "evidence_type": "literal",
          "hits": [
            "V",
            "V"
          ],
          "reasoning_match": null
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL05",
      "language": "de",
      "sentence": "Der Unterschied zwischen Gewinnen und Verlieren ist oft klein.",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF063",
      "expected_move": "Compare",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "de-compare-difference",
        "reasoning_move": "Compare",
        "intent_id": "show-a-difference",
        "pattern_id": "CLF063",
        "strength": "supported",
        "scope": "reasoning_move",
        "evidence": "explicit difference between alternatives"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF063",
          "reasoning_move": "Compare",
          "score": 16,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "show-a-difference",
            "strength": "supported",
            "evidence": "explicit difference between alternatives"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL07",
      "language": "de",
      "sentence": "Wir müssen uns zwischen Kaffee und Tee entscheiden.",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF049",
      "expected_move": "Decide",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "de-decide-between",
        "reasoning_move": "Decide",
        "intent_id": "choose-between-options",
        "pattern_id": "CLF049",
        "strength": "supported",
        "scope": "reasoning_move",
        "evidence": "explicit choice between alternatives"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF049",
          "reasoning_move": "Decide",
          "score": 16,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "choose-between-options",
            "strength": "supported",
            "evidence": "explicit choice between alternatives"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "XPRTRN003",
          "reasoning_move": null,
          "score": 6.6,
          "evidence_type": "literal",
          "hits": [
            "Wir",
            "wir"
          ],
          "reasoning_match": null
        },
        {
          "id": "XPRREG003",
          "reasoning_move": null,
          "score": 3,
          "evidence_type": "literal",
          "hits": [
            "Wir müssen"
          ],
          "reasoning_match": null
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL08",
      "language": "en",
      "sentence": "I agree with your point, but have we considered the potential risks?",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF058",
      "expected_move": "Challenge",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "en-challenge-polite",
        "reasoning_move": "Challenge",
        "intent_id": "disagree-politely",
        "pattern_id": "CLF058",
        "strength": "supported",
        "scope": "reasoning_move",
        "evidence": "softened disagreement"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF058",
          "reasoning_move": "Challenge",
          "score": 16,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "disagree-politely",
            "strength": "supported",
            "evidence": "softened disagreement"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "GRP055",
          "reasoning_move": null,
          "score": 6.2,
          "evidence_type": "literal",
          "hits": [
            "V",
            "V"
          ],
          "reasoning_match": null
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL09",
      "language": "de",
      "sentence": "Ich verstehe deinen Punkt, aber ich sehe es anders.",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF058",
      "expected_move": "Challenge",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "de-challenge-polite",
        "reasoning_move": "Challenge",
        "intent_id": "disagree-politely",
        "pattern_id": "CLF058",
        "strength": "supported",
        "scope": "reasoning_move",
        "evidence": "softened disagreement"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF058",
          "reasoning_move": "Challenge",
          "score": 16,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "disagree-politely",
            "strength": "supported",
            "evidence": "softened disagreement"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL11",
      "language": "en",
      "sentence": "Can you stay calm and focus on the issue, not the person?",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF062",
      "expected_move": "Reframe",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "en-reframe-focus-not",
        "reasoning_move": "Reframe",
        "intent_id": "clarify-what-you-mean",
        "pattern_id": "CLF062",
        "strength": "supported",
        "scope": "reasoning_move",
        "evidence": "contrastive focus"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF062",
          "reasoning_move": "Reframe",
          "score": 16,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "clarify-what-you-mean",
            "strength": "supported",
            "evidence": "contrastive focus"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL12",
      "language": "en",
      "sentence": "I think we need more data before making a decision.",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF041",
      "expected_move": "Limit",
      "expected_rank": 2,
      "move_rank": 2,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "en-limit-need-more",
        "reasoning_move": "Limit",
        "intent_id": "show-something-is-not-enough",
        "pattern_id": "CLF041",
        "strength": "supported",
        "scope": "reasoning_move",
        "evidence": "current evidence is insufficient"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF045",
          "reasoning_move": "Condition",
          "score": 18,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "state-a-prerequisite",
            "strength": "direct",
            "evidence": "prerequisite before action"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "CLF041",
          "reasoning_move": "Limit",
          "score": 16,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "show-something-is-not-enough",
            "strength": "supported",
            "evidence": "current evidence is insufficient"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL13",
      "language": "en",
      "sentence": "Yes, but not actively.",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF065",
      "expected_move": "Limit",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "en-limit-qualify",
        "reasoning_move": "Limit",
        "intent_id": "qualify-a-claim",
        "pattern_id": "CLF065",
        "strength": "supported",
        "scope": "reasoning_move",
        "evidence": "explicit qualification"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF065",
          "reasoning_move": "Limit",
          "score": 16,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "qualify-a-claim",
            "strength": "supported",
            "evidence": "explicit qualification"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "GRP055",
          "reasoning_move": null,
          "score": 6.2,
          "evidence_type": "literal",
          "hits": [
            "V",
            "V"
          ],
          "reasoning_match": null
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL14",
      "language": "en",
      "sentence": "I think we need more data before making a decision.",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF045",
      "expected_move": "Condition",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "en-condition-before-need",
        "reasoning_move": "Condition",
        "intent_id": "state-a-prerequisite",
        "pattern_id": "CLF045",
        "strength": "direct",
        "scope": "frame_structure",
        "evidence": "prerequisite before action"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF045",
          "reasoning_move": "Condition",
          "score": 18,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "state-a-prerequisite",
            "strength": "direct",
            "evidence": "prerequisite before action"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "CLF041",
          "reasoning_move": "Limit",
          "score": 16,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "show-something-is-not-enough",
            "strength": "supported",
            "evidence": "current evidence is insufficient"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL15",
      "language": "de",
      "sentence": "Ohne Hilfe könnte ich das nicht tun.",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF043",
      "expected_move": "Condition",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "literal+reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [
        "Ohne"
      ],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "lens-de-condition-ohne-koennen",
        "reasoning_move": "Condition",
        "intent_id": "state-a-prerequisite",
        "pattern_id": "CLF043",
        "strength": "direct",
        "scope": "pattern_lens_generalisation",
        "evidence": "ohne plus impossibility",
        "priority": 7
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF043",
          "reasoning_move": "Condition",
          "score": 23.4,
          "evidence_type": "literal+reasoning",
          "hits": [
            "Ohne"
          ],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "state-a-prerequisite",
            "strength": "direct",
            "evidence": "ohne plus impossibility"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL16",
      "language": "de",
      "sentence": "Ich gehe spazieren, es sei denn, dass es regnet.",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF044",
      "expected_move": "Condition",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "de-condition-unless",
        "reasoning_move": "Condition",
        "intent_id": "set-a-condition",
        "pattern_id": "CLF044",
        "strength": "supported",
        "scope": "reasoning_move",
        "evidence": "exception condition"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF044",
          "reasoning_move": "Condition",
          "score": 16,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "set-a-condition",
            "strength": "supported",
            "evidence": "exception condition"
          }
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL17",
      "language": "en",
      "sentence": "If these adjustments don't lead to improvement, we may need to consider alternative strategies.",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF070",
      "expected_move": "Test",
      "expected_rank": 2,
      "move_rank": 2,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "en-test-revision",
        "reasoning_move": "Test",
        "intent_id": "ask-what-would-change-the-conclusion",
        "pattern_id": "CLF070",
        "strength": "supported",
        "scope": "reasoning_move",
        "evidence": "explicit revision condition"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF059",
          "reasoning_move": "Cause",
          "score": 18,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "connect-cause-and-effect",
            "strength": "direct",
            "evidence": "explicit causal result cue"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "CLF070",
          "reasoning_move": "Test",
          "score": 16,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "ask-what-would-change-the-conclusion",
            "strength": "supported",
            "evidence": "explicit revision condition"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "MOD005",
          "reasoning_move": null,
          "score": 6.4,
          "evidence_type": "literal",
          "hits": [
            "may",
            "V"
          ],
          "reasoning_match": null
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL19",
      "language": "en",
      "sentence": "Let's review the impact of these changes at the end of the next quarter.",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF067",
      "expected_move": "Test",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "en-test-monitor",
        "reasoning_move": "Test",
        "intent_id": "test-an-idea",
        "pattern_id": "CLF067",
        "strength": "supported",
        "scope": "reasoning_move",
        "evidence": "explicit evaluation action"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF067",
          "reasoning_move": "Test",
          "score": 16,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "test-an-idea",
            "strength": "supported",
            "evidence": "explicit evaluation action"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "GRP055",
          "reasoning_move": null,
          "score": 6.2,
          "evidence_type": "literal",
          "hits": [
            "V",
            "V"
          ],
          "reasoning_match": null
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL20",
      "language": "en",
      "sentence": "It appears that customer complaints have increased due to shipping delays.",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF053",
      "expected_move": "Infer",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "en-infer-likely",
        "reasoning_move": "Infer",
        "intent_id": "offer-a-likely-explanation",
        "pattern_id": "CLF053",
        "strength": "supported",
        "scope": "reasoning_move",
        "evidence": "epistemic likelihood cue"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF053",
          "reasoning_move": "Infer",
          "score": 16,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "offer-a-likely-explanation",
            "strength": "supported",
            "evidence": "epistemic likelihood cue"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "CLF060",
          "reasoning_move": "Cause",
          "score": 16,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "explain-a-cause",
            "strength": "supported",
            "evidence": "explicit causal source"
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "GRP055",
          "reasoning_move": null,
          "score": 6.2,
          "evidence_type": "literal",
          "hits": [
            "V",
            "V"
          ],
          "reasoning_match": null
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PL21",
      "language": "en",
      "sentence": "They decided to call it a day.",
      "expected_pattern": "CLF069",
      "expected_move": "Decide",
      "expected_rank": 1,
      "move_rank": 1,
      "expected_evidence": "reasoning",
      "expected_literal_hits": [],
      "expected_reasoning": {
        "rule_id": "en-decide-stated",
        "reasoning_move": "Decide",
        "intent_id": "state-a-decision",
        "pattern_id": "CLF069",
        "strength": "supported",
        "scope": "reasoning_move",
        "evidence": "explicit completed decision"
      },
      "top_results": [
        {
          "id": "CLF069",
          "reasoning_move": "Decide",
          "score": 16,
          "evidence_type": "reasoning",
          "hits": [],
          "reasoning_match": {
            "intent_id": "state-a-decision",
            "strength": "supported",
            "evidence": "explicit completed decision"
          }
        }
      ]
    }
  ]
}