B2–C1 · CLF · CLF062

Not so much [X] as [Y]

A reusable frame from “Clarification and reformulation”. Repair and sharpen meaning in conversation.

EN · EnglishNot so much [X] as [Y].
DE · GermanNicht so sehr [X] als vielmehr [Y].

Try variations4 · more examples

  1. RU · Translation

    Риск связан не столько с первоначальной стоимостью, сколько с долгосрочной нагрузкой на поддержку.

    EN · English

     The risk  is not so much the initial  cost as the long-term maintenance burden.

    DE · German

     Das Risiko  liegt nicht so sehr in den Anfangskosten als vielmehr im langfristigen Wartungsaufwand.

  2. RU · Translation

    Проблема не столько в недостающих функциях, сколько в непонятных настройках по умолчанию.

    EN · English

     The problem  is not so much missing  features as unclear defaults.

    DE · German

    Das Problem  sind nicht so sehr  fehlende Funktionen als vielmehr unklare Standardeinstellungen.

  3. RU · Translation

    Успех зависит не столько от добавления новых правил, сколько от наблюдаемости существующих.

    EN · English

     Success  depends not so much on  adding more rules as on  making  the existing rules observable.

    DE · German

     Der Erfolg  hängt nicht so sehr von zusätzlichen Regeln ab als vielmehr davon,  die bestehenden Regeln beobachtbar zu  machen.

  4. RU · Translation

    Этот спор не столько технический, сколько организационный.

    EN · English

     The debate  is not so much  technical as organizational.

    DE · German

     Die Debatte  ist nicht so sehr technisch als vielmehr organisatorisch.

Use this move when you want to…

Reasoning move · Reframe

Reframe

What it does

Shift the main emphasis from one explanation or quality to another without denying the first completely.

When to use it

Use it when X is partly true but Y better captures the dominant issue.

Common mistake

Do not use this frame when X and Y are unrelated; they should compete as explanations or descriptions.

Annotated language

See this structure in context

These links are deterministic structural matches from the annotated corpus, not claims that the sentences mean exactly the same thing.

Pattern graph

Continue with nearby patterns

Related reasoning patterns3

Nearby structures let you perform the same reasoning move in a different form.

  1. The question is not whether [X], but how [Y].Reframe · same reasoning move · same study set · related logic
  2. It's not that [X]; it's that [Y].Reframe · same reasoning move · same study set · related logic
  3. The question changes once we distinguish [X] from [Y].Frame · related logic

Continue learning

Choose the next useful route.

Public corpus examples

See this reasoning move in real sentences

The source sentence contains a reviewed cue that points toward this frame. Treat it as a bridge for practice, not as an equivalence claim.

ENImproving Conflict Resolution SkillsCan you stay calm and focus on the issue, not the person?ENConflict Resolution Skills IICan you stay calm and focus on the issue, not the person?